
After any tragedy like the one we've seen in Japan, people ordinarily set aside their differences and work together to give aid to all those affected. Certainly, the differences of opinion regarding our origins seems inconsequential at a time like this. However, it is also at times like this that people ask the question, “why would God allow something like this to happen?” And in such a time, our view of origins bears directly on how we would answer.
The Bible says that when God created the world, He saw that it was all very good (Genesis 1:31). There were no earthquakes, floods, or disasters of any sort. There was no death. It was not until after Adam sinned that death entered into the world (Romans 5:12). The Bible tells us that it was at the Fall that God cursed the ground for the sake of Adam (Genesis 3:17) and the creation groans under the Curse even until now (Romans 8:22). The earthquakes and floods we see now are the result of the Curse. They are not God's perfect will but are His judgment for Adam's sin and our continued rebellion against Him. In this world, we will continue to have tribulation (John 16:33) until God restores His creation to the paradise He intended it to be (Revelation 21:1-6). To that end, He sent His Son so that whoever should believe in Him would have eternal life (John 3:16).
On the other hand, there are some Christians who believe in an “old” creation and theistic evolution. How exactly do they answer questions like this? If God used evolution to create us, then death and tragedy are intentional. If the earth is billions of years old, then this earthquake is rather ordinary. Earthquakes, volcanoes, and flooding are how God shapes the earth. Over the supposed billions of years the earth has existed, there should have been millions of earthquakes. Why then should we consider this one a tragedy? It's just another tink of God's hammer as He continues shaping the earth just as He's always done. And what about the thousands who died? I suppose they're just another step in the evolutionary ladder who have gone the way of Homo ergaster or Australopithecus.
To say that it doesn't matter what we believe about origins is to say that it doesn't matter what we believe about the character of God. Do we believe in a Holy God who is the Judge of His creation and who sent His Son to redeem us from our bondage of sin? Or do we believe in a capricious god who, for billions of years, has sent disaster upon disaster to clear the way for his next-best species of animal on his way to humans?
Let me close by saying this: I'm not exploiting this tragedy to promote my views on Genesis. Rather, I'm using it as an opportunity to show that our beliefs have consequences. If we are to be witnesses to the world, we must share the good news. And what is the good news? It is that there is life in Jesus and everyone who believes in Him will not die (John 11:25-26). There is no hope in the god of evolution. We cannot turn to him for comfort at a time like this. Death and suffering are his plan for us.