As
a Christian apologist, if I may presume to be one, I would feel slack
in my duty to God if I only answered the easiest arguments skeptics
make rather than the most difficult ones. Over the years, I've
responded to many “best arguments for atheism” articles I've
found on the web. It's been my experience, though, that none of them
are very good. Indeed, many can't even stand against their own
criticism. For example, Carl Sagan is quoted as saying,
“Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.”
Of course, Sagan didn't present a shred of evidence to support this
claim! What a riot. //RKBentley chuckles//
Anyway,
I recently came across still another article titled, 3
Famous Atheists & Their Best Arguments. As I clicked on the
link, I went through my usual cycle of emotions: curiosity,
hopefulness, disappointment, and finally, determination to at least
find something in the article worth blogging about.
Most
of the arguments in the article have been addressed on my blog
already. Perhaps those really are the best arguments for atheism
because I've heard them repeated so many times. In fact, it would
probably be a good idea to write more about them because they are
certainly arguments Christians will hear often. Regardless, there
was one point raised in the article that I don't believe I have
written about. It's certainly not an original argument, but it's
been raised often enough that I'm rather embarrassed that I haven't
addressed it before now. So let me remedy that today.
Religion
is Desperation
I've
also noticed this painful truth about religion. It's made up of
people who are intensely afraid of reality, and of the truth of the
human condition. Religion comes from our hatred for our loathsome
existence and our deep desire to deny the actuality of death and
future loss. However, if we can be united in our dissociation from
real life, we can be happy. We can call this dissociation "faith"
and together we can be free from the horror of existence.
The
article attributes this argument to Richard Dawkins but it well
predates Dawkins. The earliest and most famous (infamous) person who
raised this point is perhaps Karl Marx who said, “Religion
is the opium of the people.”
Wiki
actually cites the full quote as saying, “Religion
is the sigh of the oppressed creature, the heart of a heartless
world, and the soul of soulless conditions. It is the opium of the
people.”
The
implication is, life is really hard and people use religion like a
drug to escape from reality. There is such a tangle of problems with
this argument that it's difficult to find the best order to unravel
them.
IT'S
AN APPEAL TO MOTIVE
I
believe I should dive right in and start with the obvious: this is a
text book example of the fallacy, appeal
to motive. Think about it. Suppose I really do believe in
Christ only because I'm afraid to die. How would that make
Christianity not real? It would be like a person, dying from cancer,
rejoicing when the doctor says, “I have good news. Here's a cure!”
The sick person certainly has a reason to want
to believe the doctor but his eagerness (or even his skepticism if
he doubted) has no bearing on whether he is really sick or whether
the doctor really has a cure. To question the motive of believers,
by saying they believe in God only because they are afraid of the
world, does nothing – NOT ONE THING – to establish atheism as
being correct or theism as being wrong.
If
we looked at the opposite side of the coin, I could make this same
argument against atheists – that God is real and atheists deny
there's a God so they can live their lives however they want and
pretend there is no God who will judge them after they die. I could
say that Hell is real and the thought of eternal torment scares
atheists so much that they try to convince themselves it isn't real.
I could talk about the amazing historical evidence for the Bible,
about the evidence for the Flood, about the evidence against
evolution but atheists won't accept any of it because to acknowledge
any point means they would have to accept the possibility of a God
and that's not an option for them.
If
Dawkins truly thinks God isn't real because Christians want Him to be
real (I still can't quite figure out what point Dawkins is trying to
make), then he needs to examine his own motives. Romans 1:18-20
says, “For
the wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness and
unrighteousness of men, who hold the truth in unrighteousness;
Because
that which may be known of God is manifest in them; for God hath
shewed it unto them.
For
the invisible things of him from the creation of the world are
clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even his
eternal power and Godhead; so that they are without excuse:”
I believe the evidence for God is overwhelming. Everything I know
about reality affirms over and over that there is a God behind it
all. The Bible says we intuitively know there is a God, I shouldn't
even have to present any evidence of Him. So when atheists deny what
should be obvious, I do
question their motives. Are you ready for a dose of irony? Many
atheists only claim to be atheists because they know God is real!
IT'S
A HASTY GENERALIZATION
Besides
its faulty appeal
to motive
foundation, Dawkins deftly piles onto his argument still another
fallacy of logic, the hasty
generalization.
It's true there may be people out there who fear death so much that
they would leap at any promise of eternal life – even
an empty promise.
Yet even if that's true, it's no basis for Dawkin to suggests this
applies to all Christians or even most Christians.
The
majority of Christians believe in God and the Bible for the same
reasons people believe anything, namely, they are convinced that
these things are true. We become convinced through many different
lines reason: logic, evidence, and our experiences. It's factually
wrong for Dawkins to suggest the primary factor why Christians choose
to believe is fear.
IT'S
AD HOMINEM
It's
hilarious when an atheist acts “holier-than-thou,” but in his
typical, condescending fashion, Dawkins suggests that atheists are
enlightened thinkers who fully grasp reality while theists are
quivering cowards who couldn't leave their house without an assurance
that someone “up there” is going to keep them safe. I'm not sure
exactly why he does this. It could be simple ridicule borne out of
his habitual contempt for theism. It could be a tactic aimed at
shaming people who claim to believe. Whatever the reason, it's
rather shameful.
No
one wants to look like a coward. No one wants to be thought of as a
person who can't face reality. Yet that's what Dawkins claims
Christians are. It may be possible to embarrass a person to the
point he is afraid to admit what he truly believes to be true but
it's just a gimmick. It does nothing to prove what the person
believes isn't true.
IT
CONTRADICTS ITSELF
If
people invent religion to quell their fears of reality, why invent a
religion with hell? It doesn't make any sense. In fact, it's beyond
senseless for someone who already fears death to create a religion
where a worse punishment might await him after death! If fear were
truly the motivating factor for people to believe in God, some form
of universalism, the belief that all people can live happily ever
after, would be the most popular religion.
In
conclusion, let me remind you of the title of the article that raised
this point: 3 Famous Atheists &
Their Best Arguments.
I'll repeat that, “Their best
arguments.”
Really? Saying, “You only believe
in God because you're afraid of reality,”
is one of the best arguments for atheism? I'm sorry but it's not one
of the best. It's not even a good argument. It does nothing to
support atheism and the author should be embarrassed that he even
included it in his article.
Further
reading

